Leonard Cohen

Using Similar Rhythms Throughout a Melody Strengthens a Song

I’m often asked about motifs – how they work in typical songwriting, and if songwriters even need to be aware of them. Unlike a hook, which does its work in the foreground, a motif is a small building-block of music that works mainly in the background.

That’s not to say we don’t typically hear motifs — we do if we listen for them. But here’s the main difference between hooks & motifs: a hook is like a flag that the music waves in the air, allowing the song to be immediately identified. A motif, on the other hand, serves as a bit of melody or rhythm that strengthens the structure of a song, and works mostly in the background.

Hooks and RiffsHooks and Riffs: How They Grab Attention, Make Songs Memorable, and Build Your Fan Base” – Power up your songs by creating hooks that demand attention!

A motif appears, and then is used either as-is, or modified and developed as a song progresses. A good example of a motif at work in a pop song: “Closing Time” (Leonard Cohen).

Much of the melody is comprised of a quickly-descending figure that serves as a melodic motif:

Closing Time - Melodic Motif

That alternating between a higher note and a lower one starts out as a major 2nd interval. From there, the motif changes. Sometimes you hear it as a descending 4th… sometimes a line is sung where notes barely change at all.

When the backing singers sing the “closing time” chorus, you can hear that the motif is reversed as they bend the notes upward. That’s just one way that a motif can develop and change as a song progresses.

The fact that various melodic ideas in the song share this common motif is what strengthens the structure of a song. Producers use motifs all the time when they supervise the recording of a song. They’ll add certain backing rhythms and other ideas to the instrumental accompaniment, all designed to help glue the song together.

Instinct or Purposeful?

At the songwriting level, how much of motif-writing is conscious, and how much of it just happens? It’s probably a mixture of both in the best songwriters. Good writers have an instinct for limiting the number of discrete ideas in a song by relating several seemingly unrelated ideas through the use of a motif.

There are several words that all relate to each other, but have slightly different meanings: hook, riff, motif, groove, and so on. The importance of a good hook in pop songwriting is obvious. And most songs, if they aren’t slow ballads, will need some sort of groove to keep the listener fixated.

Motifs are one more element that can really help by having one aspect of your song “sound reminiscent” of other aspects. If you’re wondering if you’re making good use of what motifs can potentially do for you, consider the following ideas:

  1. Melodic rhythm. Try to find ways to have rhythmic ideas repeat throughout your song, so that the melody in one section in your song bears some small resemblance to another.
  2. Melodic shape. Try taking a verse melody, and reversing some aspect of it. For example, if your verse melody consists of many upward-moving shoes, try writing a chorus melody that uses mainly downward-moving ones.
  3. Chord progressions. Let’s say you’ve worked out a good chorus progression. To create one for a verse, try borrowing ideas from that progression, ideas that might sound similar to the chorus. When an audience hears both progressions, they hear them as different, but with some pleasant aspect of similarity that helps to strengthen the song.

Gary EwerWritten by Gary Ewer. Follow Gary on Twitter.

Chord Progression Formulas“Chord Progression Formulas” show you how to create dozens of chord progressions in mere moments. With lots of sample progressions you can use right away. It’s part of “The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” eBook Bundle packages. Get today’s 10-eBook Deluxe Bundle deal.

Posted in Hook and tagged , , , , , , , , .
Daniel Merriweather - Adele

Making Melody Your Song’s Most Important Ingredient

Not every song is about the melody. For songs where the melody is kind of a neutral player, you’ll typically find that the rhythmic treatments, (especially background) will step up and take a leading role. In other words, the groove and feel become very important contributors.

How you know that a melody is acting as a crucial part of the success of a  song is when you notice:

  1. its range is relatively expansive – at least an octave;
  2. it moves up and down in an attempt to mirror the emotional content of the lyrics;
  3. repeating elements, particularly repetitions that begin on different notes.

In the hope that someone might walk down the street humming your latest song melody, it’s worth looking at each of those characteristics more closely.

The Importance of Melodic Range

The fact that a melody moves up and down is a given, or else it wouldn’t be a melody. It’s more important to make note of why it’s moving up and down, and in that respect, points #1 and #2 above go hand-in-hand.

Hooks and RiffsBecause pop songs are typically short — usually 3-4 minutes in length — the hook becomes a crucial feature. “Hooks and Riffs: How They Grab Attention, Make Songs Memorable, and Build Your Fan Base” shows you how to write a hook that really grabs the attention your songs need.

Since the voice displays ever-increasing levels of emotion as it goes higher, it’s wise to partner that with the emotional content of the lyric. That feature of our voice applies even in non-musical settings. If you say in a low-pitched voice, “That’s my muffin,” someone will hand you a muffin. If you raise your voice to a relatively high range and say the same thing, someone will wonder what you’re getting all worked up about. That’s the nature of the human voice.

So as a songwriter, part of making your song’s melody effective is to move your focus back and forth between the melody and the lyric, and making sure that the more emotive parts of your lyric aren’t getting downplayed by a melody moving in the wrong direction.

Some great song melodies that demonstrate the up-and-down nature in partnership with lyrics:

  1. Here in My Heart (Pat Genaro, Lou Levinson, Bill Borelli), recorded by Al Martino, 1952. Lyrics
  2. Rocket Man (Elton John, Bernie Taupin). Recorded by Elton John, 1972. Lyrics
  3. Tears in Heaven (Eric Clapton, Will Jennings). Recorded by Eric Clapton, 1991. Lyrics

The Importance of Repetition

I talk a lot about repetition in good melodies, because it’s one of the strongest organizing structures in music. Playing/singing something once means that it’s come and gone. Sing it twice, and it suddenly rises to being a crucial structural element.

The Song “Water and a Flame“, written by Eg White and Daniel Merriweather, and recorded by Merriweather for his debut album “Love & War”, is a great example of not just how repetition strengthens the structure of a song, but also how repetition can occur in different ways.

Melodic Sequencing

As you’ll notice, the opening line happens while the melody is sequenced downward. Melodic sequencing means that a line of melody is repeated at a lower pitch, and then often repeated again at a still lower pitch. You’ll hear this on the first 3 lines of lyric:

Seven days has gone so fast,
I really thought the pain would pass.
It’s been nearly an hour…

The melody of this opening section then repeats, but it becomes rhythmic, not melodic, repetition. From there, almost every line of melody is repeated, either exactly or approximately as Merriweather improvises and extrapolates on what he’s sung on the previous line.

Advice for Strengthening the Power of a Melody

The best advice for songwriters who are looking to make their next song melody something that really steps up and gets noticed? Be sure to move your melody up and down as the emotional value of the lyric at any given moment dictates.

And to use repetition of musical phrases as an important structural element. When audiences hear music repeating, they feel more secure and feel that they understand the music much more than in songs where little is repeated.

Gary EwerWritten by Gary Ewer. Follow Gary on Twitter

3rd_ed_cover_smChapter 5 of “The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” is where you’ll discover the secrets of writing a melody that partners well with a lyric. Get the full 10-eBook Bundle, and a FREE COPY of “Creative Chord Progressions.”

Posted in Melody and tagged , , , , , , , , , , .
Guitarist - songwriter on stage

Avoid These 5 Chord Progression Mistakes In Your Songwriting

Knowing why some chord progressions your’e coming up with sound good while others just don’t work at all is an entire area of study in music schools. For many of you, though, a good chord progression is something you can come up with by improvising and by borrowing ideas from other existing progressions.

In this blog I often list the qualities of good chord progressions, but I wonder if it helps, from time to time, to simply list the things that weaken progressions. With that in mind, here are 5 characteristics of chord progressions that make them more of a hindrance than a help in your songwriting:

1. Try to mostly avoid moving chord roots to adjacent letter names.

This is what I mean: C  G  F  Em  Dm  C. That progression starts with a leap downward of a 4th (C-G), which is good. But then proceeds after that by step: G-F-Em-Dm-C. The problem with that is that it forces most of the notes of those chords to move parallel to the bass, and that’s something that’s a bit too distinctive.

“The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” eBook BundleIf you’re just looking for some chords that can jump-start your songwriting process, “Essential Chord Progressions” and “More Essential Chord Progressions” will give you hundreds of them. They come as part of “The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” 10-eBook Bundle, along with a FREE copy of “Creative Chord Progressions

There’s nothing wrong with moving a bass line step-by-step, though, as long as you mix in some chord inversions (slash chords). By using inversions, you can have the chord roots moving more by 4ths and 5ths, which makes a more satisfying progression.

So that progression above — C  G  F  Em  Dm  C — might sound better by changing one of the chords to give you this: C  G  F  C/E  Dm  C. The bass line is the same, but the chords are stronger. Even just that one change makes all the difference. Occasional movement to adjacent letter names is fine, but avoid more than 2 or 3 in a row.

2. Try to avoid moving the bass by an augmented 4th.Bass player

It can work, but its first affect is to startle: C  Am  G  A/C#  Dm. The bass note on the 4th chord is G, and the one that follows is C#. That means your bass is moving up by the interval of an augmented 4th. For that progression (assuming you’re not trying musically to startle the listener), it’s better to put that A/C# in root position: C  Am  G  A  Dm.

3. Mostly avoid progressions that make the key difficult to hear.

To be clear, I’m not talking about progressions that wander from key to key, or where the key could be debatable; those kinds of progressions can be fascinating and very useful in verses and bridges (These are called fragile progressions… See point #5 below). I’m talking about progressions in which the tonic — any tonic — is nonexistent. Here’s a progression that’s just too weird for most songs in the pop genres: C  F#m  Gm  E  A  Bb  C.

keyboard synthTo be creative in your music, I recommend targeting the lyrics and melodies as elements that work really well when stretched and manipulated. With your chords, offer a way for the listener to hear a hint of key, and leave musical weirdness to other elements.

4. Don’t keep using the same key and/or progressions.

If you’ve put an EP together where all the songs are in the same key, the audience can experience a kind of musical fatigue without knowing why. For each song you do, try switching key to keep the audience from feeling the numbness that comes from a never-changing key.

If one or two of your songs use the same or very similar progressions, find ways to use chord substitutions. You’ll also find that reworking the song to be in a different tempo and/or time signature can help divert attention away from a similar progression.

5. Don’t use fragile and strong progressions randomly.

Keyboard & GuitarA strong progression is one for which the key of the music is clear and obvious. C  Am  Dm  G  C is an example of a strong progression. A fragile progression, on the other hand, has a wandering quality, and it is usually less clear what the actual key is. Those can be fascinating and pleasantly creative when used well: Em  F  Dm  Am.. Is it A minor? Is it C major with a missing tonic? The vagueness is very evocative.

The problem is when they’re used randomly throughout a song. Fragile progressions belong mainly in song verses and bridge sections. Strong progressions work anywhere, but especially are needed in a song’s chorus.

That allows the song to move back and forth between fragile and strong, and that kind of contrast makes a song enticing to listen to.

There are always exceptions.

For each one of the problems listed above, you can find songs that actually do them, and do them successfully. Bill Wither’s “Lean On Me,” for example, famously starts with a progression where the chord roots move to adjacent letter names. But that’s an effect, and not something he’d necessarily do in any other song.

Gary EwerWritten by Gary Ewer. Follow Gary on Twitter.

Chord Progression Formulas“Chord Progression Formulas” show you how to create dozens of chord progressions in mere moments. With lots of sample progressions you can use right away. It’s part of “The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” eBook Bundle packages. Get today’s 10-eBook Deluxe Bundle deal.

Posted in Chord Progressions and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , .
Blind Willie Johnson - Sinead O'Connor

How Can Studying Old Songs Help Us to Write New Ones?

Does it seem strange to think that you might learn a thing or two about songwriting by studying hits from the past? You might love Buddy Holly’s “That’ll Be the Day” (Jerry Allison, Buddy Holly, Norman Petty), but what if you’re hoping to write the next big pop song hit? What does “That’ll Be the Day” have to do with a new song that you might be trying to write today?

Old songs — at least the ones that were successful in the past — have much to teach us:

  1. Song structure. The way songs are designed today hasn’t varied much over the past 6 decades. “That’ll Be the Day” is a standard verse-chorus design — a form that had been around since the days of Schubert songs more than 100 years earlier. For today’s songwriter: It answers the question: What does it sound like to start a song with a chorus?
  2. Song lyrics. Songs from 6 decades ago established the low-to-high emotional content of lyrics as they moved from verse to chorus. For today’s songwriter: Lyrics still need to do the job of moving the emotional impact of the music up and down. As such, that’s an important job of lyrics that still holds true today.
  3. Chord progressions. The way chords work today is precisely identical to the way they worked in Buddy Holly’s day. There are slight differences in chord choices today, but how those chords work is still the same. For today’s songwriter: It can be interesting to look at certain moments within a song’s structure (how the verse connects to the chorus, for example), and see how chord choice affects the way we hear those various sections connecting. In “That’ll Be the Day”, the verse progression ends on a V-chord — a so-called “open cadence”, which needs some sort of resolution. The chorus starts on a IV-chord, which delays the arrival of the I-chord. That’s a technique that can still work well today.

We can go on an on with this and talk about how other elements within songs still can apply today. The truth is that what makes a song sound old is the production — the overall sound. Like Sinead O’Connor’s remake of Blind Willie Johnson’s “Trouble Will Soon Be Over”, you update the sound and you’ve got a song that can sound like a new composition.

Hooks and Riffs“Hooks and Riffs: How They Grab Attention, Make Songs Memorable, and Build Your Fan Base“, is available at “The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” Online Store. Get it separately, or as part of 10-eBook Bundle, along with a FREE chord progression eBook.

It’s Not Just About Remakes

But remakes of songs isn’t exactly what I’m talking about in this post. I want to make the point that old songs can serve as models in other ways for brand new songs that we’re writing. In fact, I might even make a stronger point than that, and say that old songs are really the only reliable source of musical instruction a songwriter has today.

When being interviewed, today’s best songwriters will constantly talk about how they were influenced by songs and writers that came before. They might have heard a chord change they liked from a song 40 written years ago, or perhaps it was a kind of guitar sound, or maybe it was a key change. Whatever it is, good songwriters today seem to be frequently talking about songs that happened years ago.

The Best Songwriters are Active Listeners

The best way to be sure that you’re learning and applying the lessons learned by earlier songwriters is to engage in active listening. To actively listen means to attempt to be deliberately aware of what’s going on in a song.

It means going beyond what a casual listener would do. For anyone else (non-songwriters, in other words), it’s enough simply to know which songs you like and which ones you don’t. To learn from songwriting requires more. You need to be aware of what you like, but then you need to go a step further and identify what it is that you like or dislike.

That’s the sort of thing you can keep in a songwriting journal — a kind of mini-analysis of songs that have influenced you from past generations. To that end, do an online search for hits songs from past decades, and see what similarities there are, and what you like or dislike about them.

If you want to be the best you can possibly be, make listening — from all genres, and all eras — a daily part of becoming a better songwriter.

Gary EwerWritten by Gary Ewer. Follow Gary on Twitter.

“The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” eBook Bundle packages“The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” eBook bundle comes with a free copy of “Creative Chord Progressions”. Learn how to take your chords beyond simple I-IV-V progressions. With pages of examples ready for you to use in your own songs!


Posted in songwriting and tagged , , , , , , , , , , .

Is Motivation Different From Inspiration?

I wonder if someone has ever asked you where you find your motivation for songwriting. And if so, I wonder if you would give a different answer if they asked you to describe where you find your inspiration?

Inspiration is a favourite word for people in the creative arts. By inspiration, most artists mean the initial “spark” that causes images to form in their minds. For composers of music, those images are usually sound-based. A choreographer’s spark would be the imagining of someone’s physical movement. A visual artist’s spark would literally be images that will eventually appear on a canvas.

“The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” eBook BundleLeonard Bernstein: “Inspiration is wonderful when it happens, but the writer must develop an approach for the rest of the time.” Get “The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” 10-eBook Bundle for the rest of the time.

A couple of posts ago I wrote about inspiration as the result of our own work: as we create an artistic work (a song, for example), we get inspired by the sounds we create, and that inspiration propels us forward in the creative process of writing that song.

But motivation? That’s different, because it speaks to something longer term: not just what has inspired us to write that song, but what motivates us to be a songwriter, day after day, year after year.

Songwriters are fond of talking about initial sparks, but they don’t tend to talk a lot about motivation. And motivation — or more precisely, losing it — can be scary. Lacking the motivation to write at all is worse than lacking initial-spark inspiration, because at least without inspiration you can still write. Or even if you feel you need to be inspired, there’s any number of quick ways to generate an initial spark.

But finding yourself lacking motivation is harder to deal with because that speaks to what you might see as your purpose in life — why you’re here, so to speak.

Are you lacking motivation these days to write music? If you are, you might find any one of these to be symptoms:

  1. You question whether you really are a songwriter.
  2. You question whether you ever were a songwriter.
  3. You take criticisms of your songs hard.
  4. You find other people’s success makes you feel worse.
  5. You’re afraid of letting others (close friends and family) down.

All of those can be symptoms of losing your motivation to continue trying to write songs. There are more reasons than just those, of course. Constantly feeling that your songs are lacking in quality can also cause your motivation (along with inspiration) to take a serious hit.

How Writer’s block, Inspiration, and Motivation All Connect

I think of writer’s block as being either mild, moderate or severe. The mild kind is the kind everyone gets from time to time. For a few days, that song you’re working on just sits there unfinished.

A moderate creative block is one that lasts longer – a week or two, possibly more. Turning your attention to a different creative pursuit, like writing short stories, or perhaps painting, are great ways to deal with it.

But a severe block is different, and that’s the one that speaks to motivation. A severe case of writer’s block makes you question whether you ever were a songwriter. Maybe you were just a pretender.

If this describes you, here’s a list of ways that might help you define exactly why you became a songwriter in the first place:

  1. Sit down and remember. Think back to your first attempts at writing songs. Can you recall what made you feel excited? Just remembering what brought you to songwriting can help you find the missing motivation.
  2. Re-form your motivation. Perhaps the reasons you became a songwriter just aren’t doing it for you anymore. So come up with new reasons. There are endless numbers of reasons to choose from: you want your kids to see your creative side… you want to express your life’s philosophy through music… you want your songs to be your legacy. Whatever the reason, think it through, and then remind yourself of it every day.
  3. Connect with others. One of the best ways to stay motivated is to stay connected to other songwriters, either through songwriting circles, partnerships, performances… whatever gets you next to others. Remember, all songwriters need motivation, and staying connected to others is a great way to reciprocate and help others feel motivated.

The main difference between inspiration and motivation is that inspiration might change from song to song, but your motivation is a long-term reason for why you do what you do. To keep motivation working for you, start every songwriting session by reminding yourself why you need to write. That simple act of remembering will help you through the tough times.

Gary EwerWritten by Gary Ewer. Follow Gary on Twitter.

all_10_newJanIf you’re not sure how or why contrast is an important aspect of good songwriting… that’s Chapter 3 of “The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” eBook text. Get today’s free deal: “Creative Chord Progressions.”

Posted in Inspiration, Writer's Block and tagged , , , , , , , , , , .

Hi, I'm Gary Ewer. This blog has been my labour of love since 2008. You'll find the five most recent songwriting articles right here on this page, and if you want to browse through the more than 1500 posts in the archive, scroll to the bottom of the page.

And if you're ready to discover the extent of your true songwriting skills, you need my eBook Bundle. Read about that here.

Please feel free to leave a comment at the end of any article. I love reading what others are thinking about music.

About Gary Ewer

Stay Connected!

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Gary’s YouTube Videos

If you like seeing songwriting concepts being explained, check out Gary's YouTube Channel.

Gary's latest video: "5 Reasons to Include a Bridge In a Song's Design"

Read More Articles From the Archives:

A Welcome from Gary Ewer

Welcome! I've been helping songwriters improve their technique for many years on this blog, and I'm glad you've visited today. And I very much welcome your comments on anything you read here.

About Gary

Songwriting Manuals

Are you stuck in a songwriting rut? Gary's “The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” manuals will get you moving again. Seven high-quality PDF documents. Take your songwriting to a new level of excellence!

Read more..

Essential Chord Progressions

Discover how chords work, and how to add chords to your song melodies.

More Info