How to Make a Downward Key Change Work

“The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” Deluxe BundleGet the songwriting ebook package that thousands of songwriters are now using to take their music to its highest level of excellence. “The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” 10-eBook Deluxe Bundle is currently ON SALE. Read more..

________________

3 Doors Down - Here Without YouRegarding the changing of key within the same song (called modulation), the songs that start in minor for the verses and switch to major for the chorus are the most common kind.

Here’s how that usually works: a song might start by using the following chord progression for the verse: Cm Bb  Cm  Ab, repeated over and over. When it gets to the chorus, you might then get something like this: Eb  Ab  Eb  Bb. Depending on how those chords are used, it’s likely (or at least possible) that the verses are in the key of C minor, switching to the key of Eb major for the chorus. That’s called switching from a minor key to its relative major.

The American rock band 3 Doors Down demonstrate this with their song “Here Without You.” The verse is in Bb minor, switching to the relative major key of Db major for the chorus.

But I want now to talk about changing key so that there isn’t that kind of very close relationship. In other words, modulations where the two keys aren’t so closely related, at least from a music theory point of view. A classic example is The Who’s “My Generation”, which starts in G major, moves up to A major, then again to Bb major.

Those keys (G major, A major, and Bb major) don’t have a lot to do with each other, at least on paper. The Who used those key changes for two main reasons:

  1. to mask the fact that the song consists of a very short musical idea, repeated incessantly; and
  2. to generate musical energy by moving the melody higher.

Speaking of that second point, most modulations you encounter in music will be upward ones, for that very reason: it tends to boost musical momentum. But that’s not to say that a downward modulation can’t work, but it comes with an inherent problem: if an upward modulation boosts energy, how can you get a downward one to work (assuming you want to keep building energy throughout your song)?

A great example is The Beatles’ “Penny Lane,” the verse for which is in B major, while the chorus descends to A major. Why does it work so well? And even despite the descending key, you definitely get the feeling that the musical energy gets a bump upward in the chorus.

The reason it works so well is because of the design of the melody. The verse melody consists of short melodic ideas that are mainly downward, strung together. At the chorus, the first two short cells are upward moving ideas, giving us the highest notes of the song:

 

Verse-chorus melodic direction: Penny Lane

The chorus melody makes the new lower key work for the following reasons:

  1. The listener perceives a higher energy level that comes from the melody that starts in an upward direction.
  2. Higher vocal energy is created by placing the highest notes of the song at the start of the chorus.
  3. The chords that accompany the melody in the chorus provide a bass line that moves in the opposite direction (upward) to that of the verse (downward).
  4. The new key offers a “clean slate” — a new musical landscape.

Of all those, you’ll make a downward modulation work best if you have it happen at the same time as 1) the melody is moving upward, and 2) giving the audience the highest notes of the song.

Another example to look at is The Beach Boys’ “Wouldn’t It Be Nice“, which gives an intro in A major, and then immediately descends to F major for the first verse. That downward key change is startling, but works because the verse starts on such a high note.

______________

Gary EwerWritten by Gary Ewer. Follow on Twitter.

all_10_newJan_sm“The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” eBook Bundle packages look at songwriting from every angle, and have been used by thousands of songwriters. How to use chords, write melodies, and craft winning lyrics. Get today’s DISCOUNT PRICE.

Posted in Chord Progressions, Modulation (Key Change) and tagged , , , , , , , , , .

2 Comments

  1. Your example of “Wouldn’t it be Nice” is more apposite than you noticed.
    The Intro arpeggios are in A
    The verse is in F
    The Bridge is in D (but with the same Intro arpeggios – now adding delicious harmonic complexity) and the melody is higher – like Penny Lane.

    • Thanks for writing, and for pointing that out. You’re correct – I hadn’t noticed the bridge. As I was writing the post, the opening to “Wouldn’t It Be Nice” popped into my brain, and I didn’t think further than that.

      Thanks again,
      -Gary

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *