A Songwriter's Yearly Check-Up

How do the songs you write today compare to what you were doing a year ago?

____________"From Amateur to Ace: Writing Songs Like a Pro"

“The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” 6-eBook Bundle comes with this FREE eBOOK: “From Amateur to Ace: Writing Songs Like a Pro”. 7 Songwriting eBooks for $37

Songwriting is an art that bears many similarities to playing a musical instrument, some good and some not:

  1. Like playing an instrument, you benefit from daily practice.
  2. Like playing an instrument, you can get complacent, accepting of bad habits.
  3. Like playing an instrument, you have opportunities to share your abilities with others.
  4. Like playing an instrument, you need to get outside your comfort zone if you want to improve.
  5. Like playing an instrument, you can get in a rut and feel uninspired if you don’t listen to other songwriters’ work.

It’s very hard to measure how much, if at all, you are improving as a songwriter. One of the main reasons for the difficulty is that the quality of songs is notoriously difficult to rate. It’s hard to say, “This song is better than Songwriterthat one,” because we have so many ways to measure that elusive concept of quality. So if we can’t rate our songwriting abilities, how do we improve?

One of the best ways to improve as a songwriter is to check your progress by comparing how and what you’re writing today with what you were doing a year ago. And of course, it’s important to know what kind of changes you are hoping to see.

So check out the following questions. In a way, they are all asking the same question in a number of different ways: What kind of songwriter are you aiming to be?

Song Topics

  1. Has the kind of things you write about changed over the past year?
  2. Do you like the change that you see?
  3. Are you disappointed in the lack of progress you’ve made as a songwriter in this regard?
  4. Are the kinds of things you write about moving in a direction you like?
  5. Do you spend more time today thinking about song topics than you did a year ago?

Song Lyrics

  1. Do you use many of the same expressions and turns-of-phrase that you used a year ago?
  2. Do you find that your latest songs say things in a more concise, engaging way?
  3. Do you find that your lyrics today show a better sense of structure and design than a year ago?
  4. Are you pleased with the level of sophistication (while still remaining engaging) that your lyrics show today?
  5. Are your lyrics becoming more interesting and “quotable” than a year ago?

Song Melody

  1. Do you notice a change in the way you write a melody today as compared to a year ago? Are you pleased with the change you see?
  2. Do your melodies today show a better sense of design and contour?
  3. Do you notice a stronger connection between lyrics and melody in your songs today than one year ago?
  4. Did you start your most recent song by working out melodic details first?
  5. Do you find your melodies today are more singable, and more easily remembered than a year ago?

Chord Progressions

  1. Is there an improvement in the sophistication of your chord choices compared to a year ago?
  2. Is there an improvement in the way you use backing vocals?
  3. Do you like the progress you’ve made in how melody and chords work together?


  1. Is there a difference in the final instrumentation you choose for your songs today compared to a year ago?
  2. Do you tend toward a more varied instrumentation now compared to a year ago?
  3. Do you like the way that instruments use rhythmic ideas from the vocal line as a way of creating stronger musical structure?
  4. Have you improved as an instrumentalist over the past year?

These are just some of the questions you might ask yourself, and it helps to remember that you are in control of your own destiny when it comes to how you approach songwriting. For example, you may not notice much Rock Band in Rehearsalof a change in the way you write your song melodies, but that may be due to the fact that your primary concern is the lyric.

The good thing about those check-up questions listed above is that they draw your attention to songwriting as an art that needs to be practiced, and in that regard, you need to be improving.

A good way to proceed once you’ve gone through that list of questions, is to choose one question as your area of focus for the next few tunes you write. Then once you’ve made the effort to improve in that one way, move on to another question.

In no time, you’ll start to see the kind of improvement that you’ve been expecting of yourself.


Gary EwerWritten by Gary Ewer. Follow on Twitter.

“The Essential Secrets of Songwriting” 6-eBook Bundle looks at songwriting from every angle, and has been used by thousands of songwriters. How to use chords, write melodies, and craft winning lyrics. $95.70 $37.00 (and you’ll receive a FREE copy of “From Amateur to Ace: Writing Songs Like a Pro.“)

Posted in songwriting and tagged , , , , , .


  1. The songwriting industry has taken a mighty whack between the eyes, Smaller Publishing outfits around the Nashville area, are in trouble, some have cut right back on staff, some have closed down altogether. most were working on large bank overdrafts and since the latest recession Banks are not willing to lend anymore.
    If it was hard for new writers to get heard twenty years ago it’s even harder now.
    There are not many top songwriters around who can also produce their own songs onto a demo , it’s not something songwriters are good at and most of the demo studios in town are producing dated sounding songs.

    As Gary states the song has to be great before you go the whole hog, A good or average demo of a bad song will go no where.

    A great voice (the right voice) and a great song will get heard somewhere, keep the music simple but in tune, and let that song build to a climax, No one wants a song that goes nowhere.

  2. Pingback: Written Anything Quotable Lately? | The Essential Secrets of Songwriting Blog

  3. Pingback: Interesting Links For Musicians and Songwritiers – September 20, 2013 | Creative Music | Inspiring Musical Creativity

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.